History Warns The Fed Will Raise Interest Rates More, Not Less
“Currently, the December 2019 Fed Funds futures contract implies that the Fed will reduce the Fed Funds rate by nearly 75 basis points (0.75%) by the end of the year. While 75 basis points may seem aggressive, if the Fed does embark on a rate-cutting policy and history proves reliable, we should prepare ourselves for much more.”- Investors Are Grossly Underestimating the Fed
Our advice to plan for the unexpected was prescient. When we wrote the article in July 2019, Fed Funds were between 2.25% and 2.50%. The Fed Funds futures contracts were implying the Fed would reduce rates by .75% in the forthcoming months.
By April 2020, Fed Funds were trading near zero, 1.50% below where the market thought they would be in mid-2019. The article quantifies the Fed always raises or cuts rates much more than expected.
Today, the market is pricing in steady increases, starting in 2022, for the Fed Funds rate. Despite high inflation and low unemployment, the Fed refuses to even think about thinking about raising rates.
Given the Fed’s posture, it may appear traders are overestimating how much the Fed will raise rates. However, we caution once again; traders always underestimate the Fed.
Whether higher Fed Funds seems logical is irrelevant. As investors, we need to strategize in case history proves clairvoyant. Given the Fed is starting to normalize monetary policy, it’s worth revisiting the article from 2019.
We recommend reading the article’s first section linked above for more background on Fed Funds and their futures contracts.
The graph below shows how much the Fed Funds futures market consistently over or underestimates what the Fed does. The green areas and dotted lines quantify how much the market underestimates how much the Fed ultimately reduces rates. The red shaded areas and dotted lines are akin to today’s potential rising rate situation. They show estimates for rate cuts fall short of the Fed’s actual actions.
Per the article:
“As shown in the graphs above, the market has underestimated the Fed’s intent to raise and lower rates every single time they changed the course of monetary policy meaningfully. The dotted lines highlight that the market has underestimated rate cuts by 1% on average, but at times during the last three rate-cutting cycles, market expectations were short by over 2%. The market has underestimated rate increases by about 35 basis points on average.”
The good news, with rate increases on the horizon, is the market’s margin of error for rate increases is much less than decreases.
The Fed Funds futures markets are now pricing in a 100% chance of a 25bps rate hike by August 2022 and a second hike by year-end. They also imply two more hikes in 2023.
The graph below highlights the history of Fed Funds as well as the futures implied forecast. We also show the Federal Reserve’s median forecast.
The Fed is coy about tapering QE, let alone raising interest rates. While the forecasts shown above may seem aggressive, odds are they are conservative. Based on the last four significant rate-hiking experiences, we should expect an additional 35bps, above market expectations, of rate increases by the end of December 2022. 1% Fed Funds here we come!
Why The Market May Be Underestimating the Fed
The current environment is unique, making our quantitative forecast questionable. Simply the unique ways in which the pandemic crippled economic activity along with the massive amounts of fiscal and monetary stimulus are beyond compare.
Inflation at 5.4% is running more than twice the rate of the prior ten years. Of more significant concern, it is showing signs it may be persistent. Chairman Powell recently noted as much: “The risks are clearly now to longer and more persistent bottlenecks, and thus to higher inflation.“
The Fed has not faced such an inflationary environment since the late ’70s and early ’80s. Fractured supply lines, shortages, transportation problems, and rising wages threaten to keep upward pressure on prices. If elevated prices remain persistent, the Fed will need to act with aggression to reduce it.
If such a scenario plays out, the market may be grossly underestimating the Fed’s resolve and political pressure on them to quell inflation.
Why The Market May Be Overestimating the Fed
Economic growth is slowing rapidly. Third-quarter GDP was just 2%, well off the 6.7% pace of the second quarter. Forecasts for the fourth quarter range widely from 3-6%. However, estimates for the third quarter were also north of 5% only a month ago.
If some of the supply problems abate and economic activity remains weak, the Fed could slow their taper schedule and leave Fed Funds alone. One could argue they might taper QE only to increase monthly purchase amounts in the first quarter of 2022. In this case, Fed Funds would stay near zero.
As we wrote in Investors Are Grossly Underestimating the Fed, “the market has a long history of grossly underestimating, in both directions, what the Fed will do. The implications to stocks and bonds can be meaningful. To the extent one is inclined and so moved to exercise prudence, now seems to be a unique opportunity to have a plan and take action when necessary.”
Two years after having written those words, they remain equally important today. The equity markets and most financial assets, for that matter, are trading at extreme valuations. It is not future economic prospects driving the enthusiasm. Instead, it is the Fed’s radical monetary policy. In What is the Federal Reserve Hiding From Us? we offer investors caution. “The most inappropriate monetary policy” is the sole bedrock supporting the most egregious asset valuations in well over 100 years.”
If easy money is the bedrock of valuations and the Fed is getting ready to shift the bedrock, investors best pay attention to market forecasts and how the Fed ultimately acts.