◄ back to all posts

Weekend Reading: Markets Love Central Banks – No Matter What They Do

Written by Lance Roberts | Oct, 27, 2017

Facebook

Twitter

Print Friendly

I discussed yesterday, the apparent “myth” of the Fed’s proposed “balance sheet reduction” program as the most recent analysis shows a $13.5 billion “reinvestment” into their balance sheet which has helped fuel the recent market advance.

But therein lies the potential “fatal flaw” of the “bullish logic.”

At the September FOMC meeting, the Federal Reserve announced their latest decision which contained two primary components:

No rate hike currently, although, further rate hikes are likely in the future, and;
The beginning of the process to cease reinvestment of the Fed’s balance sheet.

That announcement was notable for two reasons:

The Fed did NOT hike rates because the underlying economic data, and, in particular, the inflation data, suggests the economy is too weak to absorb a further increase currently, and;
The unwinding of the balance sheet is generally believed to be bullish for stocks.

So, despite the clear evidence of the support for the markets provided by near zero-interest rate policy and trillions in monetary injection, it is believed that “unwinding” those supports will have “no effect” on the market. In other words, it doesn’t matter what the Fed does, it’s “bullish.”

The same is also believed to be the case for the European Central Bank and Mario Draghi who just announced yesterday that the ECB’s QE program will begin to be reduced by €30 Billion per month (down from €60 Billion). While this will continue the expansion of their balance sheet currently, “QE,” as the markets have come to know it, is coming to an end.

Don’t misunderstand me, Central Banks are still very actively engaged in the support of the financial markets for the time being which keeps asset prices positively buoyed. However, with Central Banks now “tightening” monetary policy, the risk of a policy error has risen markedly. This is particularly the case when the financial markets insist on ignoring the knock-off effects of less liquidity.

Tax Reform With Complete Disregard

Yesterday, the House of Representatives passed the Senate-approved budget. This budget is an anathema to any fiscally conservative policy. As the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget stated:

“Republicans in Congress laid out two visions in two budgets for our fiscal future, and today, they choose the path of gimmicks, debt, and absolutely zero fiscal restraint over the one of responsibility and balance.

While the original House budget balanced on paper and offered some real savings, the Senate’s version accepted today by the House fails to reach balance, enacts a pathetic $1 billion in spending cuts out of a possible $47 trillion, and allows for $1.5 trillion to be added to the national debt.

Make no mistake – this is a defining moment for the Republican party. After years of passing balanced budgets and calling for fiscal responsibility, the GOP is now on-the-record as supporting trillions in new debt for the sake of tax cuts over tax reform and failing to act on the pressing need to reform our largest entitlement programs.”

Passing fiscally irresponsible budgets just for the sake of passing “tax cuts,” is, well, irresponsible. Once again, elected leaders have not listened to, or learned, what their constituents are asking for which is simply adherence to the Constitution and fiscal restraint.

As the CFRB concludes:

“Tax cuts do not pay for themselves; they can create growth, but in the amount of tenths of percentage points, not whole percentage points. And they certainly cannot fill in trillions in lost revenue. Relying on growth projections that no independent forecaster says will happen isn’t the way to do tax reform.”

That is absolutely correct.

Here is your weekend reading list.

Trump, Economy & Fed

Fed Ignores Most Relevant Evidence by Caroline Baum via MarketWatch
Another Reason To Fear Unions by Simon Constable via PJ Media
Given Time Tax Cuts Will Work by Stephen Moore via The Washington Times
Tax Cuts Won’t Work As Well As Trump Hopes by Don Lee via LA Times
Kevin Hassett Is Betting Tax Deliver Growth by George Will via National Review
Here’s What’s Important About The Budget by Robert Samuelson via RCM
The Risk Of Income Tax Reform “In Name Only” by Brian Domitrovic via Forbes
Republicans Are NOT Cutting Taxes by John Tamny via RCM
Dem’s Fight To Keep SALT Deduction by Editorial via IBD
Trump Should Keep Yellen As Fed Chair by Editorial via USA Today
The GOP Has No Budget Plan by James Capretta via Real Clear Policy
The New Populism Isn’t About Economics by Tyler Cowen via Bloomberg
Hassett’s Flawed Analysis Of Tax Plan by Larry Summers via CNBC
Don’t Be Fooled By Corporate Tax/Wage Correlation by Paul Krugman via NYT

Markets

One Of The MOST Overbought Markets In History by Charlie Bilello via Pension Partners
Some Reasons To Worry As Stocks Rise by Jeff Reeves via MarketWatch
What Would You Do With $1 Billion by SA Gil Weinreich via Seeking Alpha
S&P 500 Matches Uncanny Record For Doing Nothing by Mark DeCambre via MarketWatch
Longest Streak Ever W/O A 3% Correction by Ryan Detrick via LPL Financial
The $1000 Bagel And Market Tops by Shawn Langlois via MarketWatch
First Cracks In The Market Appear by Michael Kahn via Barron’s
Intermediate-Term Irrational by David Merkel via The Aleph Blog
Japan Is Booming, But Not Really by Jeffrey Snider via Alhambra Partners
Low Rates: Yes, You Still Need Bonds by James Picerno via Capital Spectator
BofA: Market Implies No Way A Shock Can Happen by Tyler Durden via ZeroHedge
Buy & Hold Fantasy Reaches Fever Pitch by Richard Rosso via RIA
Volatility, The World’s Only Undervalued Asset Class by Doug Kass via RIA

Research / Interesting Reads

Is Fed Getting Gold Feet About QE Unwind by Wolf Richter via Wolf Street
The Bull, The Bear & The Tortoise by Simon Maierhofer via MarketWatch
Passive Should Never Laugh At Active by Kevin Muir via The Macro Tourist
The Market IS NOT The Economy by Buttonwood via The Economist
Shielding Seniors From Financial Fraud by Alex Veiga via USA Today
Capping 401k Contributions Worsens Savings Crisis by Robert Powell via The Street
Americans Still Terrible At Investing by Lance Roberts via MarketWatch
Understanding The Fed’s Shrinking Balance Sheet by Kathy Jones via Schwab
An Old-School Manager Builds Wealth Quietly by Landon Thomas via NY Times
Even Borderline Data Will Be Recessionary by William Hester via Hussman Funds
Bears Head For Early Hibernation by Dana Lyons via The Lyons Share
What Were You Thinking by Jesse Felder via The Felder Report

“There have been three great inventions since the beginning of time: fire, the wheel, and Central Banking.“ – Will Rogers

Questions, comments, suggestions – please email me.

Lance Roberts is a Chief Portfolio Strategist/Economist for RIA Advisors. He is also the host of “The Lance Roberts Podcast” and Chief Editor of the “Real Investment Advice” website and author of “Real Investment Daily” blog and “Real Investment Report“. Follow Lance on Facebook, Twitter, Linked-In and YouTube

Post Views: 5,870

2017/10/27