Judah Spinner: How Should Investors Approach Investing?

Written by Guest Author | Dec 17, 2020

Facebook

Twitter

Print Friendly

What defines a “wonderful business?”

I recently purchased a used vehicle off an auction site. The process was simple: I reviewed the cars currently on auction, identified the few that looked like good deals to me, and then found the one that best suits my needs.

My friend takes a different approach. He finds a car that he wants and calls all the dealers in town, offering them a really low price. He tells them that if they ever really need to move inventory and are willing to accept his offer, give him a call, and he’ll come by the dealership, cash in hand.

This difference in approach is akin to the different methods of finding attractive investments. Most people look around the stock or bond markets to see what seems to be most attractive. A smart minority considers first a group of wonderful businesses, then waits patiently to buy them at a bargain price. That brings us to the question at the heart of this article and possibly the industry as a whole.

What Defines A Great Company?

A good company is one that can earn a high return on capital employed. Let’s review an example: If I started a restaurant chain that went on to earn $100 million per annum, is this a success?

It depends on how much capital got invested in starting and operating the business. If we used $10 billion, it would equate to a meager 1% return, but if the company only used $250 million, we’d be earning a fantastic 40% return on our investment. Essentially, a profit of $100 million can only be said to be good or bad in light of how much capital the business uses.

Let’s take a minute to analyze the latter scenario. I had the great idea to set up a chain of restaurants in underserved neighborhoods in several major cities, and we were enjoying a 40% return ($100M/$250M).

Here’s the catch: It won’t be long until my fellow capitalists notice and seize on my success by opening restaurants of their own.

As they encroach on my market, we will need to compete to maintain our market share. Such may mean lowering prices (likely reducing our $100 million per annum income) or updating my restaurants, so they have more allure (increasing our invested capital). Our return on invested capital will soon take a hit, and our business won’t be so attractive anymore.

Building A Moat

So then, how does a company remain attractive for an extended period? By possessing a sustainable competitive advantage, or moat, as Buffett would call it. Such may materialize in several different forms.

Sometimes it’s a brand name (think Coke), while other times, it’ll be a patent (drug companies) or a network effect (Facebook and Google).

Let’s take Google as our example: they’ve earned a return on capital in the high teens over the last decade. They have had a near-identical sum on equity because they have had a minuscule amount of debt during most of this period. Because they have more searches performed than competing search engines (with a 92.71% market share according to statcounter.com), their algorithms can endlessly improve more quickly than a smaller competitor. Such has cemented Google as the best search engine-per the American Customer Satisfaction Index. Google scored highest among its competitors for User Satisfaction-which keeps the trend going.

A business would need to be a fool to skimp and advertise with Microsoft’s Bing with only a fraction of the audience (2.73% market share). Such is what enables Google to fend off the intruders and continually earn healthy returns. How has this worked out, you ask? Over the last decade, their income has increased more than four-fold (pre-tax income of nearly $40 billion in 2019), and their investors have received a 330% return. Google has outperformed the rise in both the Nasdaq and the S&P 500.

A Simple Comparison

Contrast the economics of Google with Posco, the third-largest steel producer in the world, headquartered in South Korea. With little differentiation between producers, steel is generally a commodity type business. As a result, Posco has earned roughly a 5% return on invested capital over the past decade. Their business demands enormous capital investments to maintain the plant and equipment necessary to remain competitive and provide only meager returns on said investment. That is an example of mediocrity, if not worse.

So how have their investors faired?

Sales have gone nowhere, profits have decreased in the decade since 2010, and shareholders have seen a decrease in their holdings price.

Even The Best Company Will Not Justify An Infinite Price.

McDonald’s has a long history of earning excellent returns on invested capital due to its brand name and scale. Such provides them enormous leverage with their suppliers. During the early 1970s, the market recognized much of its potential and bid up its share price. At the height of the “Nifty Fifty” (of which the company was a member) in January of 1973, McDonald’s sold for 86 times earnings, at about $0.96 per share adjusted for splits.

As investors came to their senses, the price plummeted 68% to just $0.30 in 1974. It took until mid-1982 to break the high price set in ‘73. That’s more than 9-years!

No matter how excellent a company is, paying too high of a price is never a good idea.

Conclusion And A Lesson.

“We should invest like my friend buys his cars. Find wonderful businesses that we’d love to own, and only then patiently wait until, by the stupidity of the markets, someone will sell us a stake at a fantastic price.”

JUDAH SPINNER is the Founder, President, and Chief Investment Officer of BlackBird Financial. Mr. Spinner has over 10-years of experience as a security analyst. He bought his first stock at age 13, began raising capital from clients at 15, and was managing more than one million dollars at the time of his 18th birthday. On behalf of his clients and his account, Mr. Spinner outperformed the S&P 500 8 out of 10 years, racking up an annual compounded return of more than 18%. Mr. Spinner specializes in equity investments with a long-term time horizon and plays an integral role in the firm’s work.